Don't Let a Casual Phone Greeting Cost You The Job

June 30, 2025

That "Unknown Number"? It Could Be Your Dream Job Calling.

You’ve done the hard work. You’ve perfected your CV, written a killer cover letter, and sent off applications to your dream companies. You're scrolling through TikTok when your phone buzzes. It’s an unknown number. You ignore it. Or worse, you answer with a casual, "Who's this?"


Big mistake.


In a world of DMs, texts, and emails, we've forgotten the art of a phone call. But for recruiters and hiring managers, it's still a vital, and often the very first, point of personal contact. That initial phone screen can make or break your chances before you've even had a chance to talk about your skills.

I’ve been fortunate enough to work with some incredible, fast-paced brands like Gymshark, Nadine Merabi, and CurrentBody. These are dream employers for many, and the competition is fierce. What I've seen time and time again is that the candidates who succeed are the ones who are prepared at every single stage. Answering your phone professionally is stage one. Failing at this first, simple hurdle can, and will, take you out of the running for an opportunity that could change your life.


Why Your Phone Manner Matters More Than You Think


Imagine you're a recruiter. You have a stack of 100+ applications for one role. You need to create a shortlist, and quickly. You start making calls.

  • Candidate A: Answers with a loud, "Alright?" You can hear music blasting in the background. They sound distracted and completely unprepared.
  • Candidate B: Answers with a clear, "Hello, [Your Name] speaking." They sound alert, polite, and professional.

Who are you more likely to proceed with?

It’s a no-brainer. The first impression is everything. A professional greeting instantly tells the recruiter you are organised, serious about your job search, and respectful of their time. Answering like you’re talking to your best mate suggests the opposite. You might be the most qualified person for the job, but a sloppy phone call plants a seed of doubt about your professionalism and communication skills.


How to Answer the Phone Like Your Future Depends on It (Because It Might)


It’s simple to get this right. From the moment you start applying for jobs, treat every unknown number as a potential employer.

  1. Find a Quiet Spot: If you can, step away from noise and distractions before you answer. If you're in a loud place and can't move, it's okay to say, "I'm so sorry, I'm not in the best place to talk right now. Would it be possible to call you back in 5 minutes?" This shows consideration.
  2. Use a Professional Greeting: Ditch the "Yo," "What's up," or just a mumbled "Hello?" A simple, confident, "Hello, [Your Name] speaking," is perfect.
  3. Speak Clearly and Smile: It sounds cheesy, but smiling when you talk actually changes your tone of voice, making you sound more friendly and approachable. Enunciate your words and speak at a moderate pace.
  4. Be Prepared: Have a notepad and pen handy to take down names, numbers, and interview details. Keep your "elevator pitch" – a 30-second summary of who you are and what you're looking for – fresh in your mind.
  5. Voicemail is Your Backup: If you miss the call, make sure your voicemail greeting is professional. "Hi, you've reached [Your Name]. I can't take your call right now, but please leave a message and I'll get back to you as soon as possible."

Getting a call from a company you admire is incredibly exciting. Don't let a moment of casualness ruin your chances. By being prepared and professional from the very first "hello," you're showing a potential employer that you're the polished, capable, and hire-worthy candidate they've been looking for.


About Emma Green



Emma Green is a seasoned Fractional People Director with over 20 years of recruitment experience working with leading global brands. Known for her expertise in talent acquisition, people development, and organizational strategy, Emma has helped businesses scale and thrive by building strong, high-performance teams. Passionate about leadership and the human side of business, she delivers tailored HR solutions that drive long-term success.

For more tips and advice on recruitment and people management, follow Emma on Instagram @askemmahr.


By Emma Green August 18, 2025
Why Every Employee Needs Their Own Care Label
By Emma Green July 17, 2025
In today's hyper-competitive talent landscape, the traditional CV is rapidly losing its reliability as a hiring tool. With AI-powered writing assistants crafting compelling narratives and platforms like Canva enabling anyone to create visually stunning presentations, the polished facade has never been more misleading. The question facing every recruiter and hiring manager is no longer whether a candidate can present themselves well, it's whether they can actually do the job. The Great Deception: When Perfect Presentations Hide Performance Gaps We're living in an era where a candidate's ability to leverage technology can mask fundamental skill deficiencies. A beautifully designed CV created in minutes using Canva templates, combined with AI-generated content that perfectly mirrors job descriptions, can make virtually anyone appear like the ideal candidate on paper. But here's the harsh reality: your next hire's success won't be determined by their graphic design skills or their ability to prompt ChatGPT. It will be determined by their capacity to solve real problems, navigate complex challenges, and deliver tangible value to your organisation. The Skills That Matter: IQ Meets EQ in the Modern Workplace In our fast-paced, competitive business environment, technical competence alone isn't enough. The most valuable employees possess a combination of hard skills (the measurable, job-specific abilities) and soft skills like emotional intelligence, adaptability, and collaborative problem-solving. Can your potential software developer actually write clean, efficient code under pressure? Does your prospective trader understand market dynamics beyond textbook theory? Can your marketing candidate create compelling campaigns that drive real results, not just aesthetically pleasing presentations? These are the questions that matter, and they can't be answered by scanning a CV or conducting a standard interview. The Solution: Skills-Based Testing That Cuts Through the Noise Skills-based assessments are the antidote to recruitment guesswork. By implementing targeted testing throughout the hiring process, we can move beyond assumptions and into evidence-based decision-making. Whether you're evaluating: Coding proficiency through real-world programming challenges Trading knowledge via market simulation exercises Language abilities through comprehensive proficiency tests Analytical thinking using numerical reasoning assessments Leadership potential through situational judgement scenarios These tools provide objective, measurable insights into a candidate's true capabilities. Building Skills Assessment into Your Recruitment Process The most effective recruitment strategies integrate skills testing at multiple touchpoints, creating a comprehensive evaluation framework that reveals both technical competence and cultural fit. This approach doesn't just identify who can do the job; it identifies who can excel in your specific environment whilst contributing to your strategic growth objectives. The key is customising assessments to reflect the real challenges your team faces. Generic tests won't cut it. Your evaluation process should mirror the actual work environment, time pressures, and collaborative dynamics your new hire will encounter. The Competitive Advantage of Evidence-Based Hiring Organisations that embrace skills-based recruitment gain a significant competitive edge. They make faster, more confident hiring decisions. They reduce costly mis-hires. Most importantly, they build teams capable of executing their strategic vision rather than just looking good on paper. In a world where anyone can create a compelling CV, your ability to see beyond the surface and identify genuine talent becomes your greatest recruitment superpower. Ready to transform your recruitment process and build a team that drives real results? For more information on how you can recruit your ideal team to meet your strategic growth targets, reach out to me. About Emma Green Emma Green is a recruitment strategist and talent acquisition specialist who helps organisations build high-performing teams through skills-based hiring methodologies. With extensive experience across diverse industries, Emma partners with clients to develop customised recruitment processes that go beyond traditional CV screening to identify candidates who can deliver measurable business impact. Connect with Emma to discover how you can transform your hiring outcomes and accelerate your business growth. emma@sandbeckgreen.com
By Emma Green July 7, 2025
It's Alcohol Awareness Week, and it's time businesses reconsider their relationship with alcohol in the workplace.